July 7, 2000 No one likes taxes,
especially those who pay a lot of them. For those who think they pay a
lot, an effective way of keeping Uncle Sam's greedy hands to himself and
out of your wallet is via municipal bonds.
Municipal bonds, or munis, are debt obligations issued by states,
cities, and other government entities to raise money to build schools,
highways and hospitals, among other things. In most cases, the income
generated by munis is exempt from both federal and state taxes, and
hence, offer the biggest benefit to those whose taxes are high.
"A person
in a high tax bracket should definitely own munis," says B. Clark
Stamper, manager of Evergreen Tax-Free High Income B (VMPIX),
a $352 million diversified portfolio of 300 high-yield munis.
The
long-term return of equities is roughly 11% while the pre-tax equivalent
dividend yield (interest income) on this fund is 10% (assuming a 40% tax
rate).
"But this
[fund] is significantly less risky than the stock market," notes
Stamper.
He says
studies show that a 20% stock and 80% municipal bond combination
offers the best risk/return combination for individuals in a 20% bracket
or higher. That means those fortunate enough to have struck it rich in
the recent tech boom should own munis.
"Many of
the newly wealthy should be worried about protecting [their earnings]
rather than maximizing return," explains Stamper. "This is a fund where
you can take some money off the table and get a better return for a much
lower amount of risk."
Out of
the Junk Yard
Stamper is a fixed-income veteran, learning his craft during the
junk-bond heyday in the 1980s. He managed a junk fund for eight years as
well as two mortgage funds, before managing this muni fund beginning in
1990.
"This is
the only one I manage now," he says. "The market is so inefficient and
it offers so much value for shareholders." The average muni size is $10
million to $20 million with 7,000 different issues, explains Stamper.
"A lot of
the big guys won't bother with some of these little bonds," he says.
Because many of these forgotten issues don't get priced accurately, he
can get better risk/reward characteristics.
"On the
muni side, high yield doesn't necessarily mean high risk," he says.
Sensitivity Training
The fund has lower interest-rate risk than other high-yield funds
because its duration is only four years. Duration is the weighted
maturity of a bond's cash flows, and is used to determine the price
sensitivity with respect to interest-rate movements.
A shorter duration means the bond is less
sensitive to changes in rates and vice versa. In a rising interest-rate
environment, as we are in now, shorter-duration bonds like munis are
better able to weather the storm (when rates rise, the yield demanded on
a bond also rises, but prices decline).
"Under most
scenarios, munis do better than most bond categories," says Stamper.
So far this
year, the fund's 4.28% total return -- interest and principal -- places
it in the fourth percentile of the muni short category, according to
Morningstar. More impressive is its 5.59% ten-year annualized return,
which puts it in the sixth percentile. Assuming a 40% tax rate, the
pre-tax equivalent 10-year return is 9.32%.
However, in
1998 and 1999 the fund ranked among the worst. Both outperformance and
underperformance have much to do with the fact that this fund falls in
the longer duration end of its category. This means that in lousy bond
years -- as in the prior two -- this fund will perform worse than its
shorter-term peers.
Stamper
points out that 1999 was one of the worst bond markets in history, and
especially hard hit were bonds other than US Treasurys.
Cheap
Relatives
High-yield munis generally have higher ratings than junk taxable bonds,
which means there is less risk of default by the issuer, or less credit
risk. The weighted average rating of the bonds in this fund is AA --
higher than the average high-yield muni fund and certainly more so than
a high-yield junk bond fund.
Moreover,
most of the portfolio (74%) is comprised of bonds that are secured by
the likes of US Treasurys, GNMA, FNMA, or corporations and 48% of the
portfolio is insured.
However,
the credit quality of the fund has not always been this high. Stamper
explains that five years ago, the average rating of the fund was BB+
with 45% of the portfolio in non-rated bonds. That's because investors
were compensated by a much higher yield to take on the higher risk. But
since that time, spreads have tightened up dramatically, meaning yields
have come down, approaching those of US Treasurys.
Still, the
muni market is cheap relative to US Treasurys, says Stamper. According
to Bloomberg, 30-year AAA-rated munis trade at a 5.57% yield -- a
pre-tax equivalent of 9.28%. This compares with the 30-year US Treasury,
which trades at 5.79%.
"[Munis]
are a little bit riskier credit wise, but not that much," he says.
Minimum
initial investment is $1,000. While Evergreen Tax-Free has a relatively
high expense ratio at 1.82%, as well as varying level loads, the
management company expects to reduce expenses by about 0.1%.
|