15:41 10Jan07
-ANALYSIS-Time to take profits in high-yield muni funds
By Dean Patterson
WASHINGTON, Jan 10 (Reuters) - U.S. investors may want to
stop plowing record sums into high-yield tax-exempt bond funds
because the oversized returns of recent years are about to end,
leaving a lot of downside risk.
Investors who are particularly concerned about capital
preservation may also want to take some of their cash out of
high-yield munis now to avoid potential price declines in the
future, money managers advised.
High-yield munis have greatly enriched investors in recent
years and investors have responded by dumping large amounts of
cash into this very small part of the $2.3 trillion tax-exempt
bond market.
But all or at least most good trades eventually end,
usually when least expected.
High-yield muni funds took in a record $10 billion of new
cash in 2006, exceeding the prior record of $8.4 billion in
2005, according to flow tracker AMG Data Services.
In fact, investors have pumped nearly $22 billion into
open-ended high-yield muni funds in the last three years and
the entire class of funds only totals about $58 billion,
according to AMG data.
High-yield munis represent only about 4 percent of the muni
bond market, based on the weighting of Lehman Brothers' widely
followed indexes.
"All this money chased a small amount of supply. That
explains why they
did so well and why there is no downside
protection now,"
said Clark Stamper, manager of the Evergreen
Strategic Municipal
Bond Fund in Corona Del Mar, California.
The focus on high-yield munis has been nothing short of
intense lately.
High-yield muni funds represent only about 16 percent of
the entire open-ended muni fund universe on a total assets
basis, according to AMG data. But high-yield funds accounted
for 61 percent of inflows over the last two years, and an even
higher proportion over the last four years.
Institutional investors have been as eager to buy
high-yield munis as retail fund investors in recent years,
money managers said.
"Right now no one cares about risk. It has been a good time
to reach for quality for more than a year," said Kenneth Woods,
chief executive officer of Atlanta-based Asset Preservation
Advisors Inc. "We have been trying to upgrade our portfolios as
much as we can."
Overdone fund inflows is just one of several red flags that
have appeared in recent quarters pertaining to high-yield
munis, money managers said.
Historically tight credit spreads between high-yield and
top-quality munis and low absolute yields are other key signals
that investors are not necessarily getting paid enough in extra
yield for the risk they are taking on with high-yield munis,
money managers said.
High-yield munis have lower credit quality which generally
translates to bigger price declines when economic fundamentals
weaken significantly or investors suddenly decide to shed
credit risk en masse, money managers said.
High-yield munis have had a good run due to improving
fundamentals, strong demand for yield, and being
under-appreciated in the past, investors said.
High-yield munis as an asset class posted a total return of
more than 50 percent during the last four years, compared to
more than 19 percent for high-grade munis, according to
Lehman's indexes. All or most of that yield is exempt from
federal taxes.
Bond fund managers usually can not match index performance
because their funds carry fees and they usually hold a portion
of their assets in cash.
The average high-yield fund posted a total return of 29
percent over the last four years, exempt from federal taxes,
according to data from Lipper, a Reuters Company.
The typical high-yield muni fund charges a 116 basis point
annual fee, according to Lipper. This gives fund investors even
less downside protection in a downturn because fund fees
usually do not go down when returns do.
The typical high-yield muni fund yielded 4.39 percent at
the end of 2006, down from 4.71 percent at the end of 2005,
according to Lipper. Falling yield is another sign of less
downside protection.
((Reporting by Dean Patterson))